Stop Virginia's Attack on Homeschool Freedom
and Religious Liberty
Say "NO" to Senate Bill 1031
“Oh, so you’re one of those whackos…”
I was trying to get a read on him as the elderly gentleman approached me. I didn’t sense hostility… but I didn’t sense a kindred spirit, either.
“Yep,” I replied. “Crazy as can be.”
The scene was Senate Room C in the Virginia State Capitol building. I arrived about an hour early for an Education and Health subcommittee hearing in the Senate.
The old man who engaged me wore a suit and tie, and he came across as very serious. We were the early birds who found our way to the subcommittee room before anyone else.
I’ll come back to our conversation in a minute – and I’ll share with you what the elderly gentleman revealed to me. But first, please allow me to set the stage...
My name is Joe Withrow. I’m a husband, father of two young children, a published author, and I founded and run an investment membership called The Phoenician League. That’s my day job.
In addition, I co-founded and help run a non-profit organization called Foundation for Human Civilization. I’m also active in our church, and I serve as Treasurer for our church’s local council.
I’m blessed to be engaged in work that I’m passionate about. I believe very strongly that living a life of purpose is the highest ideal we can strive for. That’s a value I hope to impart to my kids as well.
All that’s to say – attending senate subcommittee hearings isn’t high on my priority list. In fact, going to this particular hearing was a first for me. That’s why I arrived so early. I didn’t know what to expect.
My wife had been telling me for years that I should take a full day off work. So I did... to go to a hearing at the Virginia Senate.
I don’t think that’s what she had in mind. But I’ll tell you – I was motivated.
You see, we’re a homeschooling family. My wife helps organize our local homeschool co-op. Over twenty families participate in it. They gather once a week.
Our kids work through a formal homeschooling curriculum on each of the other four days of the week. They take all the normal classes you would expect – reading, math, science, social studies, history, literature, typing... and then a wide range of exciting electives.
We want our kids to get a wholesome, well-rounded education that will prepare them for life in our fast-moving modern world. We also feel that it is our moral responsibility to help them grow in their own spirituality as well. As such, we homeschool under the religious exemption here in Virginia.
This requires us to write a letter to the local school board each year. In it, we must explain why we are tasked with educating our children in an environment that fosters spirituality. We believe that to fall short on our obligations would be a violation of our religious standards.
And that’s how I found myself at the Senate’s Education and Health subcommittee hearing. They were considering a bill – S.B. 1031 – that seeks to eliminate the religious exemption for homeschooling here in Virginia.
And that brings us back to my conversation with the elderly gentleman. I tried to articulate my concern to him:
“If one assumes good faith, one would expect every bill proposed to seek to address a clear, objective, and measurable problem. That’s not the case here. This bill would negatively impact a tiny minority group of people… and do absolutely nothing for anybody else. It’s nothing more than an attack on homeschool freedom and religious liberty.”
And the numbers back me up here. The official data shows that less than 8,000 children are currently homeschooling under the religious exemption in Virginia. Meanwhile, the state’s population of school-aged children is roughly 1.3 million.
So we’re talking about a tiny minority group of people. The senate bill would negatively impact 0.6% of Virginia’s children – a fraction of one percent.
Yet, what would happen for the other 99.4% of Virginia’s school-aged children?
Nothing. Not a thing would change for them. They would continue about their lives just as they had before. They would never know this bill existed.
I’m not sure how this could be viewed as anything other than a dedicated attack on a small minority group of people – Virginians who homeschool under the state’s religious exemption.
To me, that means this is also a fundamental attack on the principle of religious liberty… something fundamental to our country’s very essence.
The old man nodded his head.
“You’re right,” he answered – his serious tone unchanged. “But there have been cases where parents have claimed the religious exemption and then neglected the children. There was even a murder in one family claiming the exemption a number of years back.”
“That’s not specific to the religious exemption,” I stated. “Those sound like instances of individual bad actors. There will always be bad apples… with anything.”
The old man nodded his head.
“I agree with you. But you have to understand how they think. To them, you’re just some whacko who doesn’t know what’s good for himself or his children. They see themselves as saving the kids... not attacking them.”
It turns out the man had been a homeschool lobbyist for the last 40 years. He began to explain to me how the legislature works on the inside... and he started to list the other bills put forward by the patron of S.B. 1031. It turns out she had a laundry list of bills moving through process.
Our conversation was interrupted by a knock at the door. It was a mother and her three children. We let them in.
The room began to fill up from there. People settled in. Some engaged one another in discussions. Others read through the notes they had brought in preparation.
More than a few families made their way in – no doubt homeschoolers who were just as appalled as I was. It became clear that there would be a lot of opposition to the bill.
And that’s when a Capitol employee showed up flabbergasted.
“Umm… you guys aren’t supposed to be in here,” the man was deadly serious. “These doors stay locked until the clerks arrive for the hearing. They are the ones who will let you in. Please step outside until they get here…”
I couldn’t help but chuckle at the absurdity of it.
Here was a group of thoughtful, responsible people gathered in a luxurious conference room paid for by their tax dollars… and this man seemed to think it was of vital importance that everyone wait outside.
Looking around, I could see plenty of people shared my thoughts. Still, we respectfully gathered our belongings and exited the room to wait in the hall.
Once the last person had left, the man shut the doors and made sure that they were locked. Satisfied that his job was complete, he disappeared down the long, winding hallway of the General Assembly wing – off to do who knows what.
Meanwhile, we waited for the clerks to graciously let us back into the room that some of us had just spent an hour in. Looking around, I could tell it was going to be a packed house.
The clerks arrived to let us into the conference room right at the hearing’s appointed time. They then took their place in front of the hallowed high-back senator chairs in the front of the room – looking very nervous. Each of them appeared to be in their early 20’s.
It wasn’t clear to me what their job function was, aside from unlocking the doors to let us in. But those poor kids were left to sit there in a room full of homeschool advocates for over half an hour while everyone waited.
That’s right – the first senator was over 30 minutes late for the hearing. Two others arrived shortly after that.
Upon walking in, the senators did not make eye contact with anybody. They seemed to make a point of this. They made their way to their respective chairs on the platform in the front of the room without acknowledging anyone.
Then the senators sat down and proceeded to shuffle papers around incessantly – their eyes glued on their desk. Not once did I see them look up at the people gathered before them.
This went on for another 20 minutes or so before the subcommittee Chair made an announcement: the hearing would begin as soon as the other two senators arrived. He gave no explanation or apology for them being so late.
Several minutes later he hit us with a curve ball…
“Given our time constraints, we won’t be able to review each bill today,” he announced without looking up at the audience. “S.B. 1031 will go by for the day. We’ll pick it up on Monday.”
The audience looked at each other in disbelief.
Not only did the subcommittee keep us waiting for nearly an hour – after we all took the day off to be there… they also unilaterally decided not to review the bill that most of us came to oppose. No doubt they were hoping for a lighter turn-out the following week.
However, the subcommittee Chair did offer something of an apology this time…
“I’m sorry, but that’s just the nature of the beast,” he said with an awkward smile. He didn’t seem to realize the irony in his own statement.
The subcommittee did indeed review S.B. 1031 the following Monday – in front of a lighter opposition audience. They voted to move the bill forward by a count of 3 to 2. Senators VanValkenburg, Pekarsky, and Locke voted for the bill.
From there, S.B. 1031 moved to a vote before the full Education and Health committee. It passed by a count of 9 to 6. Senators VanValkenburg, Pekarsky, and Locke voted for the bill once again. They were joined by Senators Hashmi, Lucas, Favola, Boysko, Bagby, and Aird.
Going in, I couldn’t figure out how in the world those senators who supported the bill would be able to defend it. How do you explain your support for an overt attack against 0.6% of the population?
Well, it turns out the old homeschool lobbyist I met knew what he was talking about. The supporting senators painted themselves as saviors.
The bill’s patron, Senator Pekarsky, claimed that the religious exemption deprived children of a sound education. She went on to explain how too many of our kids were missing out on a proper education... and how the exemption was the only thing in place to prevent government from solving the problem.
And she had a trick up her sleeve.
Senator Pekarsky arranged for ten young adults to come forward in support of her bill. These individuals claimed to have been homeschooled under the religious exemption, and they each said that it deprived them of the education they wished they received.
I don’t think I’ve ever felt the urge to shake my head in utter disgust and chuckle whole-heartedly at the same time.
By that logic, should we consider abolishing the public school system if ten people stand up and claim that it did not serve them well?
Of course not. Because we understand that all families are in unique situations. Who are we to tell them how they should raise and educate their children?
We also understand that all children are gloriously unique individuals. They have different talents, challenges, likes, dislikes, and temperaments.
And we know that everybody learns differently. That’s true of all of us – not just the children. There are various frameworks that have laid out numerous different learning styles. What works for some people just doesn’t work as well for others.
This is why it’s silly to eliminate one form of education based on the comments of ten individuals. And that’s taking those comments at face value, assuming no conflicts of interest...
I’m quite sure the senators supporting S.B. 1031 agree with that statement. I guarantee that they would oppose a bill to abolish their favored method of education based on the poor experience of ten people.
So clearly there’s an agenda at work here. A faction within the Virginia Senate is actively working to attack homeschool freedom and religious liberty in the state.
But here’s the thing – those of us who homeschool under the religious exemption aren’t out there trying to impose our beliefs on anyone else.
I mean, we represent 0.6% of the schooling population. We’re a tiny minority. We simply seek the same freedoms available to all Virginians, and indeed all Americans.
I’m especially appalled by this overt attack because it impacts me directly. But I think this is an issue that everyone who supports freedom should be concerned about.
If this speaks to you, I humbly request your support in our opposition to Virginia’s S.B. 1031. Let’s stand for liberty together. Here’s how...
For those who live in Virginia, please contact your state senator and your state delegate. Ask them in your own words to stand for homeschool freedom and religious liberty by opposing S.B. 1031.
You can find your representatives here: https://whosmy.virginiageneralassembly.gov/
If you aren’t in Virginia, I’ve listed those senators who voted for S.B. 1031 in the committee hearing below. Feel free to contact each of them to politely express your disgust for their open attacks on liberty in Virginia.
I doubt one or two of us would have much of an impact on them... but there is strength in numbers. At the very least we’ll make sure their staffers realize that they are aiding and abetting injustice.
Senators who voted for S.B. 1031
Again, we should be polite in voicing our opposition to the bill. The more calm and articulate we are, the more of an impact we’ll have. They want to see themselves as heroes... but our calm opposition will sow the seeds of doubt in their minds.
In conclusion, thanks very much for allowing me to share this story with you. I can’t thank you enough for your time and support.
As the late Martin Luther King Jr. once said: Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.
If you would like to follow this story further, the Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA) is doing great work out in the field. They are providing timely updates on S.B. 1031 (and other threats to homeschooling) here: https://hslda.org/legal/legislation
Sincerely,
Joseph Withrow
Concerned Citizen
P.S. That's me and my wonderful family in the picture. The senators attacking us may see us as numbers and statistics, but I promise... we're real people.
Questions or Comments? Send to:
jwithrow@phoenicianleague.com